Skip to content

2023 Baseball Corridor of Fame: Seven storylines to observe and a prediction earlier than Tuesday’s announcement


The outcomes of the BBWAA vote for the 2022 Baseball Corridor of Fame class will probably be revealed Tuesday evening. A lot of the intrigue on this vote will revolve across the likelihood Scott Rolen makes it, the features made by a number of gamers (particularly Todd Helton) and the way Alex Rodríguez and Carlos Beltrán fare.

The full 2023 poll could be considered right here. The foundations: A participant is eligible to be positioned on the poll after 5 years of retirement. Gamers who get at the very least 75 p.c of the returned ballots from certified BBWAA voters acquire entry to the Corridor of Fame. Those that get beneath 5 p.c fall off the poll. These between 5 and 75 p.c can stay on the poll for as much as 10 years. BBWAA members who’re energetic and in good standing and have been so for at the very least 10 years can vote for wherever from zero to 10 gamers annually.

No matter what goes down within the BBWAA vote, there’s already one new Corridor of Famer within the 2023 class: Fred McGriff. He made it by the use of the Modern Period Committee vote held through the winter conferences.

Listed here are the small print for Tuesday’s choice present:

2023 Baseball Corridor of Fame class announcement

  • Time: 6 p.m. ET | date: Tuesday, Jan. 24
  • television channel: MLB Community (protection begins at 4 pm ET and lasts 4 hours)
  • reside streaming: fuboTV (strive without spending a dime)

Under are six storylines to observe for because the vote totals get unveiled Tuesday evening. NOTE: Once I point out “polling,” I am speaking about Ryan Thibodaux’s poll tracker (it is not likely a ballot a lot as gathering ballots, however that is the simplest solution to succinctly body it).

1. Is that this Rolen’s yr?

Scott Rolen’s climb within the vote has a “when, not if” really feel to it. It is truly greater than really feel. Final month, I went by means of latest historic voting tendencies to point out that Rolen is overwhelmingly more likely to get in.

It nonetheless issues whether it is this yr or subsequent or the yr after, although. First off, from a human perspective, certainly Rolen is worked up to get in and if he simply misses the minimize, it is one other yr of ready. By way of massive image Corridor of Fame voting, it is a spot on the poll and clearing them helps each different official candidate. Keep in mind, voters solely have a most of 10 spots on their poll and a few Small Corridor voters restrict themselves artificially past that. Extra succinctly, the faster Rolen will get off the poll, the simpler it’s for each different participant to make features — together with subsequent yr’s newcomers like Adrián Beltré, Joe Mauer and Chase Utley.

Polling exhibits Rolen has likelihood to get to the wanted 75 p.c, however he appears to have a fairly respectable likelihood to fall barely brief. He was polling at 71 p.c final yr and the precise vote revealed him at 63.2 p.c. Proper now, he sits at 80 p.c in polling and if there is a related shortfall in non-public ballots, he’ll be only a few p.c shy of creating it.

As I stated, it is gonna be shut. That is the place a lot of the drama is for the vote Tuesday evening.

2. Nonetheless low numbers for A-Rod?

A-Rod have a polarizing case. We already know that. I firmly consider it is a large yr in balloting for A-Rod. If he makes massive features, there’s an opportunity he’ll make the Corridor down the street. If he does not, he is more likely to find yourself in Bonds Land. I went way more in depth on the speculation right here.

The numbers proper now do not bode nicely for A-Rod. Polling exhibits he is solely gained two votes from final yr (when he was 161 votes shy of enshrinement). It is at all times potential there is a cache of personal votes for A-Rod, however there weren’t final yr. Proper now, it appears like he’ll fall in need of 40 p.c and if that is the case, it is exhausting to see him making up sufficient floor transferring ahead to get to 75 p.c.

3. How does the sign-stealing scandal have an effect on Beltrán?

We have been in a position to get a common thought of ​​how the gamers linked to PEDs could be handled, generally-speaking, with the voting physique for years. In Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, we’ve got two all-time greats who by no means examined optimistic whereas there was testing, however had been closely linked. In Rafael Palmeiro and Manny Ramirez, we have had gamers who posted Corridor of Fame offensive numbers however examined optimistic. In A-Rod, nicely, you already know.

We do not have comparability with this voting physique for Beltrán, although, and it’d present a roadmap on how issues will unfold for Jose Altuve and others down the street. This is my prolonged dialogue on his case and the matter of the sign-stealing scandal.

Polling exhibits that he is about 15 p.c above A-Rod, in order that’s most likely signal for Beltrán. There have been a couple of voters who’ve written that they’ve held a vote for him this yr however would give it some thought once more subsequent yr. If he can get round 50 p.c of the vote, I will estimate, he has an opportunity to get in down the street. If he finally ends up down nearer to A-Rod, we’ll say low-40s, he is most likely in for a protracted 10 years.

Except for seeing if Rolen will get in or not, that is the storyline that can most garner my consideration Tuesday evening.

4. Helton on the transfer

However what if Rolen is not the one participant with an opportunity to make it?

Final yr, Helton bought 52 p.c of the vote in comparison with Rolen’s 63.2 p.c, however Helton has made important features. He is up 28 votes already and is polling only a single vote behind Rolen, sitting at 79.4 p.c. It might be a tremendous leap ahead, however it actually looks like the voting physique as a complete has strongly warmed as much as Helton’s candidacy.

His is a little bit of a polarizing case, however not for causes of scandal. He performed his complete profession with Coors Area as his residence. I examined the matter right here.

If there is a massive upset on Tuesday evening, it’s going to be Helton changing into a Corridor of Famer.

5. Look ahead to features

Let’s regulate the next gamers other than these talked about above:

  • Billy Wagner: After leaping almost 30 factors in two years to 46.4 for the 2021 vote, Wagner made extra modest features to 51 p.c final yr. Nonetheless, polling exhibits he is gained 29 votes this voting cycle. That is his eighth yr of him and a terrific likelihood, with all of the poll clearing from the final voting cycle, to make a leap into sensible territory.
  • Gary Sheffield: After an enormous two-year leap to 40.6 within the 2021 vote, Sheffield stagnated to precisely 40.6 p.c once more. That is his ninth yr on the poll and he wants an enormous leap to have an excellent distant shot subsequent yr. Polling exhibits 24 gained votes to date, so perhaps he is on his manner, although, realistically, the shortage of features final yr doomed him.
  • Andrew Jones: Little greater than an afterthought lingering on the poll in his first two years, Jones hit 19.4 p.c in 2020, 33.9 p.c in 2021 and 41.1 p.c final yr. Now in his sixth poll, the tracker has him gaining 22 extra votes. It appears like he’ll prime 50 p.c or perhaps even 55? If the latter is the case, he is nicely on his solution to eventual enshrinement.
  • Bobby Abreu: He solely bought 8.6 p.c of the vote final yr, however has gained 11 votes to date in polling. It is his fourth strive from him.
  • Andy Pettitte: In his fourth voting cycle final yr, Pettitte bought 10.7 p.c of the vote and has gained 12 votes this time round.
  • Jimmy Rollins: He bought 9.4 p.c of the vote in his debut final yr and has received three votes this time.
  • Mark Buehrle: He stayed above the edge in every of his first two tries (5.8 p.c final yr) and has gained eight votes.

Wagner and Jones could be the large ones to observe whereas it is potential Buehrle and Rollins barely keep alive.

6. Who falls off?

  • Jeff Kent: It is his swan track; his tenth and last yr of him. Even with an honest final-year bump in polling knowledge, he is most unlikely to even get to 60 p.c. I detailed right here that his case will most likely fare a lot better in committee and the way it is a blessing in disguise for him.
  • Torii Hunter: With solely 5.3 p.c final yr in his first strive, Hunter barely stayed alive. His public features from him are modest sufficient to consider there’s an opportunity he falls below 5 p.c.
  • Francis Rodriguez: It is the primary yr for Okay-Rod and it appears like he’ll survive, however it’s more likely to be very shut. Polling exhibits him round 9 p.c, however as a better, my guess is he loses some earlier than the vote is revealed.
  • Omar Vizquel: He is very more likely to survive. He is polling proper with Okay-Rod, however the remaining Vizquel voters are almost all non-public. He gained almost 14 p.c final yr between poll monitoring and the precise voting outcomes. He is nonetheless lifeless within the water so far as his possibilities of making the Corridor, although, right here in his sixth strive.
  • Not one of the remaining first-timers on the poll have gotten a public vote but. These are Bronson Creek, Matt Cain, R.A. Dickey, Jacoby Ellsbury, andre ethier, JJ Hardy, john lackey, Mike Napoli, Johnny Peralta, huston avenue, Jered Weaver and Jason Werth. Even when a couple of of them get a vote or two, they’re all one-and-dones.

Of these going through the 5 p.c threshold, I will predict Hunter falls off whereas Okay-Rod and Vizquel survive.

The one different individual on the poll I have never but talked about is Manny Ramirez. He very probably stays in no-man’s land with Vizquel, albeit for various causes. He bought 28.9 p.c of the vote final yr and his polling exhibits stagnation.


Again on Nov. 22, I predicted this class could be McGriff and Rolen. I nailed the committee vote with McGriff entering into alone, so let’s make it two for 2 in getting the BBWAA one right as nicely. Rolen goes in and that is it from this vote.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *